Would have to go with Tubes, though there is at least some bias there given it was the first time I saw Alizee.
Admittedly I've probably only watched the pour Laurette version once, maybe twice.
As MrCoucou mentioned, the colours, saturation and general 'glow' in the Tubes edition gives it a real edge. Makes it feel almost unreal, adds to that sense of mystique especially when watching it for the first time.
I try my best to avoid watching Tubes. The video was that magical upon first seeing it, I fear watching it too often would lessen the experience. Not to say it would be 'ruined', of course not, but I don't want to over-indulge.
I hope I don't come off as trying to sound pretentious or profound, the video is just that good.
__________________
|