Hypothetical question; Who do you save?

[SupaKrupa]

No. Not well said, bob.

Originally Posted by Bob

so there would be no chances of banging her, as i'm sure many of the men on this forum want to do, all you could develop is a close relationship.

First, you're on the wrong forums to think that all we want to do is "bang" her.

Originally Posted by Bob

and a somewhat close relationship with a superstar who would most likely drift off and forget about you.

Second, as bird said, it's selfish to save your sibling no matter the circumstances. That quote in itself is selfish to think you're only saving someone for something in return.

Originally Posted by Bob

they still care for you.

Originally Posted by Bob

seriously, a new low. take the family member, and don't be sorry.

Third, read my post about family. I don't want to say anything more that might imply I've got a bad family. If not. Here's a hypothetical: A druggo, murdering, stealing sibling or a friend?

[Edcognito]

Originally Posted by Bob

this thread has just angered me enough to post. "

Dude - take a breath and relax - its just a forum, about a French Pop-Star. Your reaction reminds me of people that can't tell the difference between shooting pixels on a screen, and having it happen in real life....

__________________________________________________ ___________
" who would never forget and thank you constantly, and be forever in debt"

Of course, i've known / run into some people who would forget it as soon as it happens. . . . You can never tell . . .

__________________________________________________ ____________
. and of course realize that Alizee has a husband, and hopefully is very happy with him. so there would be no chances of banging her, "

Now your imputing motives to people you don't even know . . . . And its a fairly offensive statement . . .

__________________________________________________ ____________

seriously, a new low. take the family member, and don't be sorry.
P.S. I'm not that close with my sisters, but that doesn't change anything. you still have to care so much for them, they're family!

And i have a situation here in New York, where a guy named "Buckey" Philips shot three state troopers - and his family helped him by hiding him, getting him money, and moving him around. . . . Should they "still have to care so much for them, they're family!"?


In my opinion - the question originally asked was a rhetorical question - no need for you to get so P.O.'d dude. . . .

Ed

[Edcognito]

Originally Posted by Matrix

Bob is right, this thread is a new low. I have a saturday night live sense of humor and sometimes I make threads that are waaay out there.

Agreed... Brad or any administrator could you please delete this thread? Merci

I apologize to anyone who was offended
Sincerely,
Matrix

You didn't offend anyone - IMHO -

And this thread doesn't need to be deleted. . . .

just IMHO.....

YMMV ....

Ed

[CK]

i agree with bob, id save my sister anyday over someone i have never met
i think alot of people would save there sister in a situation that invloved them dieing, it doesnt make you any less of a fan if you choose your sister over alizee

unless someone can give me a good reason why i should save a stranger over someone i have spent my entire life with, ill always save my sister

[Matrix]

You know I've been thinking about this scenario over in my head and let's switch the thrust here, how would Alizee react while she was in the water, knowing it was your sister in trouble too?

I bet Alizee would scream out... "save your sister!. don't worry about me!" That would make my decision alot easier. I would still swim to Alizee first because I know she said that only to be nice.