which signature do you like best

Capn · #1 09-10-2007, 07:44 PM

well as the topic says I can't decide which of these signatures to use so I'm asking you all for your opinion so should I use my current one or this new one I just made

Calisto · #2 09-10-2007, 08:03 PM

My vote would be for the second one. Like the actual hair look in comparison to the cap look. Both are good though

Deus_Ex · #3 09-10-2007, 08:27 PM

her posture, outfit, lighting, and photography make her look too fat in the 2nd picture, an obvious visual trick.

I prefer the first picture, but without the cartoon fairies.

Capn · #4 09-10-2007, 08:28 PM

well they are tinkerbell and she loves tinkerbell and I think i added to that effect in the second one with the cartoony effect I threw in there

Deus_Ex · #5 09-10-2007, 08:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Capn

well they are tinkerbell and she loves tinkerbell and I think i added to that effect in the second one with the cartoony effect I threw in there

can you make the first one without the cartoon fairies and the phrase Capn?

i would love to use it for my signature.

thanks

Cooney · #6 09-10-2007, 08:43 PM

I'd stick with your current one. The faeries pop a little too much on the other one for my tastes.

CFHollister · #7 09-10-2007, 08:48 PM

Not that I want to be negative... Personnally I don't think you should go with either. Not that they are bad (they are actually quite nice images), or that you didn't put time into them, it's just that such large, esp. tall, sigs tend to take up too much screen/board space and start to get in the way of the readability of the boards. I tend to think of a "signature" as an actual graphical interpretation of a signature; that short and long graphics are really the best suited. That's just my opinion on sigs, not your work (which is really quite nice; don't get me wrong).

Capn · #8 09-10-2007, 08:54 PM

lol trust me I have dealt with criticism in the department of signatures you didn't have to assure me its not my art because I would appreciate the opinion but I'll respect your opinion and if it really really bothers you and you would like me to change it I will with that said if cfhollister doesn't have a problem with it sure deus I'll do it but lets see if CFHollister wants us to not use these signatures first with that said I'm off to make a new one that isn't too tall

heyamigo · #9 09-10-2007, 08:54 PM

yes, although they are nice, sigs need to be horizontally long, not vertically.

Capn · #10 09-10-2007, 08:57 PM

well personally I always thought of that as an opinion but of course I'll respect your wishes as I like them both ways and like these forums and don't want any contraversy just give me some time to make a new one have it done in an hour maybe